Gage & Tollner Restaurant

Year
1875
Style
Italianate
City
Brooklyn, NY
Gage & Tollner Restaurant
Photo: Steven J from New York City, USA, CC BY 2.0
See it on the map

Gage & Tollner has occupied the lower two floors of this converted four-story brownstone at 372 Fulton Street since around 1889, after Charles Gage's original restaurant, founded in 1879 and renamed for partner Eugene Tollner in 1882, outgrew its first location. Built in 1875 in the Italianate style, the building became a favorite of judges, politicians, and businessmen, and the Dewey family ran the restaurant here for nearly seven decades starting in 1919. It's both a National Register listing and a New York City landmark, with the facade and interior separately protected.

the style

The building is Italianate, a mid-1870s commercial style, though the restaurant's fame rests less on its architectural vocabulary than on its long, continuous run of ownership through the twentieth century.

More on Italianate

significance

Gage & Tollner is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and both its facade and interior are individually designated New York City landmarks (LP-00836), a distinction that protected the restaurant's historic interior even as ownership changed hands repeatedly, from a 1988 sale to a partnership led by Peter Aschkenasy to Joseph Chirico's 1995-2004 run and a 2021 reopening under St. John Frizell, Sohui Kim, and Ben Schneider.

nearby

All 84 buildings in Brooklyn